The Community Gets the Shaft!

Battery Park City - Redux - The Extell/Carlyle Group Riverside Center  

Amended Restrictive Declaration  

Amended Restrictive Declaration

School in Riverside Center Restrictive Declaration.pdf 234.0KB Mar 30, 2011 2:23 PM
Riverside Center RD 2010.pdf 3.0MB Mar 30, 2011 2:25 PM

No Park, Just Privately Owned Open Space  

“The project would contain approximately 2.8 acres of publicly accessible, privately owned open space located mostly west of Freedom Place South.” From the Amended Restrictive Declaration.


Does this look like a park to you?



Coalition's Proposal for Riverside Center - A People's Plan. A Real 2.4 Acre Park Built First Before Any Building.  

Coalition's Proposal for Riverside Center
A People's Plan That the City Planning Commission and City Council Should Have Approved!

Coalition hired a noted architect, Craig Whitaker, to analyze the Extell private open space and create a truly Public Park on the site. His drawing and recommendations are below.
  • All the new streets are "mapped" and built by the developer before the buildings are constructed.
  • A 2.4 acre Public Park is built first by the developer. That allows the community to enjoy the park before the project's 2019 expected completion.
  • The developer turns over title to the park to the Parks Department.
  • The park is maintained through contributions from units surrounding exactly like Riverside South Park.
  • The buildings surrounding the park would look more like New York and less like "towers in the park.

Community Board 7 Rejects Extell's Proposal  
Coalition for a Livable West Side Rejects Extell's Proposal  
Coalition Opposes Extell-Carlyle Group's Riverside Center Overdevelopment

Riverside Center - Battery Park City on the Upper West Side

 

We will aggressively fight the Extell proposed Riverside Center (West 59th-West 61st Street, West End Avenue to Riverside Boulevard) by hiring consultants (Traffic, Sewage, Urban Planner etc.) who will thoroughly examine Extell's Draft Environmental Statement.

We, the community are up against powerful forces - the Extell Development Corporation and its partner, the Carlyle Group now have Orange Sands LLC, an Oman limited liability company as investors with a $613 million loan to Extell for the Riverside Center project. Gary Barnett, President of Extell, would not disclose if the Oman investors are private or government-related.

In order to protect the health, environment and quality of life on the Upper West Side (because no development occurs in isolation) we must, with your help, fight this proposal. There will be important meetings to attend. We will notify you of dates, times and places.

7-month Public Review Process

We have heard that on April 26, 2010, the Department of City Planning (DCP) will "certify" the horrendous Extell proposal for the development of Riverside South between 59th and 61st Streets (Parcels L/M/N) for which special permits are needed. "Certification" begins the 7-month Public Review session


A few basic facts:
Residential units:
Extell proposes to build 2,500 residential. Adding an additional 2,500 units, as proposed, would bring the total number of residential units to 7,992, an increase of 2,292 units over the approved limit of 5,700 units in the 1992 Riverside South Restrictive Declaration.

Parking:
The 1992 Restrictive Declaration provided for a total of 3,500 parking spaces in Riverside South from 59th to 72nd Streets. Extell is requesting 1,800 parking spaces in Riverside Center (59th-61st Street). The 1992 Restrictive Declaration provided for a maximum of 743 parking spaces on this site. Extell's proposal adds a total of 1,057 additional parking spaces to the maximum number set forth in the 1992 Restrictive Declaration.

Extell's proposed garage would cover over thirteen acres and would be the largest in Manhattan.

Proposed Out-of-Scale Towers on West End Avenue:
Extell's planned building for West 61st Street and West End Avenue has been increased in height to 53 stories and its planned building on West 59th Street and West End Avenue has been increased to 54 stories.


Coalition's position:
The City Planning Commission must insist that Extell adhere to the maximum density in the 1992 Restrictive Declaration for this site (59th -61st Street). The City Planning Commission must deny the increase in zoning that Extell has asked for.

In addition:
There must be a Public Park and all the streets built upfront by the developer;
the entire Public School, not just the shell of the school must be built by the developer;
there must be a minimum of 20% affordable housing units;

and parking spaces must be limited to 743 parking spaces as per the 1992 Restrictive Declaration. Since parking is in part a function of density, limiting spaces is one indirect way of reducing density and reducing traffic.

The Coalition submitted a plan to Community Board 7 which: adheres to the 1992 Restrictive Declaration allowable square footage; does not require excavation beneath the park; gives the community a park at the beginning; and eliminates over six acres of potential parking.

We thank you for your membership and support.

Many, many thanks.

Madeleine Polayes and Batya Lewton, on behalf of CLW and the residents of the Upper West Side

--This was sent by the Coalition for a Livable West Side to its members.

Manhattan Boro President Scott Stringer Rejects Extell Plan  

Man Boro President Stringer Rejects Extell Plan

rsc_report_by_bp.pdf 146.7KB Mar 31, 2011 1:58 PM

MBP Scott M. Stringer Announces Conditional Disapproval for Proposed Riverside Center Development


New York, August 31, 2010 – “Manhattan Borough President Scott M. Stringer announced today his conditional disapproval of the proposed Riverside Center development on Manhattan’s Upper West Side.  The recommendation addresses modifications and authorizations sought by real estate developer Extell for the final phase of “Riverside South,” a large-scale development spanning West 59th Street to West 72nd Street, approved in 1992 by the City Planning Commission and City Council.


“...the Borough President’s recommendations identifies several areas that necessitate improvement and modification.

“The current proposal lacks good site planning, creates inactive streetscapes, and obscures access to the proposed open space.  Additionally, the proposed project has many environmental impacts that require real mitigations. The Borough President’s recommendation advocates for the inclusion of public amenities such as a public school of an appropriate size to meet the needs of the community and additional active recreational space.  These, among other proposed modifications, are consistent with recommendations proposed by community members.


“In July, Community Board 7 voted overwhelmingly against eight out of eleven proposed actions and expressed a general conclusion that the Riverside Center proposal failed to meet its core principles based on similar issues of concern to the Borough President.”


Boro President Stringer Rejects Extell Plan

rsc_report_by_bp.pdf 146.7KB Mar 31, 2011 1:50 PM

More to Come - Still Updating the Site